Catastrophism and Alternative Cosmologies
The Reading Room
$Revision: 1.30 $ -- A note about this site: I am working with another enthusiast, who, like me, has his own 'main' site. We both wanted to present resources in the area of catastrophism and alternative cosmologies. Presented below are lists of books, reviews of some, suggestions for others.
[Worlds in Collision] by Immanual Velikovsky, 1950, in three paragraphs; annotated to make sense. Original descriptive text by Alfred deGazia. Very short. [Reviews of Worlds in Collision] gathered by Duane Vorhees. More extensive. ["The reaction to Velikovsky"] A reasoned recap of the history and efforts of Velikovsky, is provided by James P. Hogan in an essay which can be found here. In Section 5 the antics of the objections to Velikovsky become theater. From a book of collected essays by Hogan, Kicking the Sacred Cow (2004). See his site at [www.jamesphogan.com] for more. [Cosmic Heretics] Brian Moore's review of Alfred De Grazia's book of 1984. "the most continually engrossing of all de Grazia's books to date -- particularly for the non-specialist as it tells a fascinating story, replete with an all-star cast of remarkable characters." ["Breathtaking nonsense"] Clube and Napier's meteor and comet book, The Cosmic Serpent (1982): some critical notes.
Four additional Clube and Napier reviews:
- A review sprinkled with exuberant enthusiasms like "a superbly crafted book" by [Martin Beech].
- A somewhat critical review by [David Morrison], a former NASA employee, published in Skeptical Inquirer.
- A critique of Morrison by [Leroy Ellenberger].
- Finally, a devastating review by [Bernard Newgrosh] which voices many of my objections.
[An incomplete review of] The Cycle of Cosmic Catastrophes (2006), by Richard Firestone, Allen West, and Simon Warwick-Smith, which proposes a galactic supernova as the source for the destruction at the start of the Younger Dryas. I stopped the write-up in 2009. [The Chinese in America] 1421, the year China discovered America (2002) by Gavin Menzies. Interesting reading of a narrative built on the supposition that the Chinese Treasure Fleet circumnavigated the globe decades before the Europeans did so. The supporting data is slim at times, and dead wrong at other times, and there are a few other complaints, but overall it is very interesting reading, demonstrating the use of a retro-analytical method of investigation. [Thoth Newsletter] Probably the most interesting and informative of documents on the web dealing with the Saturnian Polar Configuration, written during the formative period in the theoretical development from 1997 to 2004. Originally at 'Kronia.com', but since March of 2010 the site has been scuttled. Alternate sets of documents are available [SaturnianCosmology.org] and at [OtherGroup.net].
URL of this page: https://saturniancosmology.org/contrarybooks/index.php
This page last updated: Saturday, December 5th, 2020
Feel free to email any comments or corrections.
jno (at) saturniancosmology (dot) org
I'll be glad to add your relevant reviews
Copyright © 2010 - 2021 Toledo Plasma Works
Permission to reprint in whole or in part is granted,
provided full credit is given.