Culture Magazine * Forums HOME > CULTURE > HISTORY Göbekli Tepe: Series Introduction Posted on the 12 October 2011 by Cris The 11,000 year old archaeological site of Göbekli Tepe in southern Turkey is undoubtedly one of the most important in the world. German archaeologist Klaus Schmidt began the ongoing excavations at Göbekli in 1994. Besides being a huge undertaking (less than 5% of the site has been uncovered), the finds -- and claims associated with them -- have been extraordinary. In a nutshell, these claims are: * Göbekli was built and used by nomadic hunter-gatherers rather than sedentary agriculturalists. * It was a religious or ritual pilgrimage center that attracted people from far and wide. * The massive stone structures or megaliths were "temples" or world's earliest "churches." * It shows that complex organized religion preceded the domestication of plants and animals or Neolithic Revolution. Why are these extraordinary claims? Because hunter-gatherers aren't supposed to be doing these things and the order is wrong. Göbekli Tepe: Series Introduction Before Göbekli, the consensus was that the domestication of the plants-animals was a condition precedent to the construction of megaliths and organized worship. After Göbekli, the causal arrows were supposedly reversed. If correct, this is heady stuff: it would mean that ideas and symbols led to or caused the single most important change in the history of humanity. There is no "civilization" without agriculture or food production. Under the Göbekli scenario proposed by Schmidt and others, religion is not mere superstructure: it is base. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, which Göbekli supposedly provides. But does it? In the October 2011 issue of Current Anthropology, University of Toronto archaeologist Edward Banning challenges the Göbekli claims. Banning's article raises important questions about what has been found and how it has been interpreted. Because the Göbekli claims and counterclaims are foundational, I will be covering them in a series of posts. In the first, we will look at the site itself and the extensive (sometimes sensational) press coverage, including interviews with Klaus Schmidt. In the second, we will examine Schmidt's professional publications and site reports for Göbekli. In the third, we will look at the questions raised by Banning in "So Fair a House: Göbekli Tepe and the Identification of Temples in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic of the Near East." Finally, we will assess the whole to determine whether the extraordinary Göbekli claims are supported by sufficient evidence. Although Göbekli surely is not (as Spiegel suggested in a 2006 cover story) the lost Garden of Eden, its archaeological and historical importance is undeniable. By the end of the series, we should have a better fix on Göbekli and the claims surrounding it. Is Göbekli an archaeological or metaphorical Stairway to Heaven? I kid but watch the video anyway. Reference: Banning, E.B. (2011). So Fair a House: Göbekli Tepe and the Identification of Temples in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic of the Near East Current Anthropology, 52 (5), 619-660 DOI: 10.1086/661207 ResearchBlogging.org Share You Might Also Like : * Göbekli Tepe: Houses of the Holy? * Göbekli Tepe: Series Conclusion * Göbekli Tepe: The Claims * Göbekli Tepe: Site & Surrounds IFRAME: http://www.facebook.com/plugins/like.php?href=http://en.paperblog.com/ gobekli-tepe-series-introduction-78474/&layout=standard&show_faces=fal se&width=467&action=like&font=arial&colorscheme=light&height=30 Add a comment Send to a friend Report spam/abuse Print this article Share on Facebook See the original article Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog These articles might interest you : * Göbekli Tepe: Publications & Reports In 1994 Klaus Schmidt discovered Göbekli Tepe and in 1995 he began the ongoing excavations. In 1998 Schmidt published his first site report. To date, Schmidt ha... Read more The 17 October 2011 by Cris CULTURE, DEBATE, HISTORY * #55 Gobekli Tepe, Part Deux Stonehenge was built 5000 years ago in 3,000 BC and the pyramids of Giza in 2500 BC. Carbon dating of organic matter adhering to the megaliths of Gobekli Tepe... Read more The 19 July 2012 by Grasshopper BODY, MIND, SPIRIT, HISTORY, RELIGION, SPIRITUALITY * #54 Urfa Man - Gobekli Tepe The world's oldest statue is a two-meter high statue of a male that was discovered in Balikligöl in 1993. The limestone statue the eyes of which are carved out... Read more The 13 July 2012 by Grasshopper RELIGION, SPIRITUALITY * NARS Blush Swatches and Review Series - Introduction Good morning everyone! I hope you had a good nights rest! I completely knocked out but I think it's because I need to get into bed earlier. Read more The 21 August 2012 by Abeautyfullday HAIR & BEAUTY, LIFESTYLE * NARS Blush Swatches and Review Series - Introduction Good morning everyone! I hope you had a good nights rest! I completely knocked out but I think it's because I need to get into bed earlier. Read more The 21 August 2012 by Abeautyfullday HAIR & BEAUTY, LIFESTYLE Add a comment Username* ____________________ Email* ____________________ Website ____________________ ________________________________________ ________________________________________ ________________________________________ ________________________________________ ________________________________________ ________________________________________ ________________________________________ ________________________________________ ________________________________________ ________________________________________ (Submit) Save Editor's Pick See the original article Report spam/abuse About the author Cris 10 votes Author's Latest Articles * Perspectival "Costumes" and "Art" * Meaning of Life: Alienation & Animism * Essentialized "Islamists" * Phallic Rivers of Faith See more Magazines * Culture * Debate * History * Religion ____________________ Submit [In all Magazines] MOST POPULAR FROM CULTURE * Today * Of the week * Of the month * Eduardo Kobra's Niemeyer Tribute by Invisiblemadevisible * Heart Smarts: The History Of The Heart Symbol by Gerard * Otsuka-Gofukuten kimono store by Yusuke Seki by Thelayer * Golestan by Ashleylister * the moth grand slam winner tara clancy by Evolutionnow * rare violins of new york and "a late quartet" by Evolutionnow * Nikon D800 dream-team: a few suggestions for choosing new lenses for your new camera by Artborghi * Ordinary Thunderstorms by Drharrietd * The `Italian' Composer from Campinas - Part Four: Carlos Gomes, a Spent Force by Josmar16 * Steve McCurry: Portrait of an Afghan Girl by Evolutionnow * Book Review - The Starboard Sea by Amber Dermont by Isabel Costello * UK Puts India Rape Statistics to Shame by Cilaw All articles MOST RECOMMENDED IN CULTURE * Of the Week * Of the Month * Of the Year * Eduardo Kobra's Niemeyer Tribute by Invisiblemadevisible * The Vital Pragmatism of Futurists by Realizingresonance * Once Bitten...Twice Shy by Superconductor * Review: The Long Quiche Goodbye by Avery Aames by Girllostinabook * the moth grand slam winner tara clancy by Evolutionnow * Michael L. Printz Nominees & Winner Announced! by Storycarnivores * Book Review - The Starboard Sea by Amber Dermont by Isabel Costello * Review: Mrs. Lincoln's Dressmaker by Jennifer Chiaverini by Girllostinabook * Artist: Sam Spratt by Iheardin * Where the Streets Have No Name...Just Art by 2bemag * Artist: Diego Fazio - Photorealistic Pencil Drawings by Iheardin * Cartoon Skeletons by Sadanduseless All articles COMMUNITY CULTURE BLOGGER OF THE DAY Clarissayjada About the author TOP MEMBERS * hookedblog 238976 pt * KenA 173447 pt * invisiblemadevisible 139528 pt * RealizingResonance 135508 pt Join ON THE CULTURE FORUM * Maison & Objet 2013 In Photos Reviewed by Launa * Movie review - Hyde Park on ... Reviewed by Gaydar * Welcome to Paris! CDG Terminal 1 Reviewed by Heriberto * Hayes Valley clothing store for aether ... Reviewed by Nyhetsbrev See all posts Home Submit Your Blog Follow us [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] Username ____________________ Password ____________________ [_] remember me (Submit) Login Forgotten your password? Paperblog * Culture + Art & Design + Books + Theatre & Opera + Photography + Architecture + History * Entertainment + Movies + TV & Video + Music + Media + Celeb * Society + Politics + Debate + Charity + Women's Issues + Current * Lifestyle + Hair & Beauty + Fashion + Shopping + Wedding + Life Coach * Health + Healthy Living + Diet & Weight + Medicine + Psychology * Sports + Basketball + Baseball + Soccer + Fitness + Football + Tennis + Moto + Athletics + Golf + Other Sports * Travel + Vacation + Expat + Destinations + Languages * Business + Economics + Finance + Career + Marketing & Ads + Real Estate + Legal * Tech + Computing + Social Media + Gaming + Gadgets * Science + Biology + Chemistry + Physics + Astronomy * Food + Drink + Recipes + Dining Out + Organic + Vegetarian & Vegan * Home + Arts & Crafts + Interior Design + Home Improvement + Gardening + Parties + Pets * Family + Marriage + Divorce + Parenting + Schooling + Community * Spirituality + Body, Mind, Spirit + Religion + Philosophy * Environment + Eco-Living + Animals & Wildlife + Weather * Outdoors + Trek + Snow + Sea * Humor + Viral + Satire + Random * Love & Sex + Relationships + Dating + LGBTQ + Erotica * Self Expression + Creativity + Rants n' Raves + Diaries * Not yet a member? * Submit Your Blog * + Home + Contact + Careers * + About Us + Terms of Service + Privacy Policy * + Paperblog in the Press + F.A.Q. * + Submit Your Blog Paperblog Tweets by @paperblog_fr