*SUBSCRIBE TO NEW SCIENTIST* Click Here New Scientist Space Log in Email Password Remember me Your login is case sensitive * Forgotten your password? * Subscriber? Activate now! * Register now * Subscribe now * Institutional Subscribers * Athens login close My New Scientist * Home * News * In-Depth Articles * Blogs * Opinion * TV * Galleries * Topic Guides * Last Word * Subscribe * Look for Science Jobs * SPACE * TECH * ENVIRONMENT * HEALTH * LIFE * PHYSICS&MATH * SCIENCE IN SOCIETY Home |Space | News < /section/science-news > High-energy portrait of approaching comet released * Updated 16:09 23 February 2009 by *Maggie McKee* * For similar stories, visit the *Solar System* and *Comets and Asteroids* Topic Guides A space telescope that usually studies the most powerful explosions in the universe has set its sights on an approaching comet. Its observations at ultraviolet and X-ray wavelengths should help reveal the comet's composition, structure and its interaction with the solar wind. Comet Lulin, which was discovered in 2008 by astronomers at the Lulin Observatory in Taiwan, will make its closest pass near Earth on 24 February. At that time, it will come within 61 million kilometres, or 40% the Sun-Earth distance, from our planet. Amateur astronomers have been watching the approaching comet, which is bright enough to be visible with the naked eye from dark sites (see this image taken by Jack Newton). Now, NASA's Swift space telescope, designed to study cosmic explosions called gamma-ray bursts , has released an image of the comet. 'Quite active' The icy body is shedding gas and dust as it nears the Sun, whose ultraviolet light breaks apart the comet's water molecules into hydrogen atoms and hydroxyl (OH) molecules. Swift's Ultraviolet/Optical Telescope (UVOT), which can detect the hydroxyl molecules, found that they fill a cloud more than 400,000 km across. "The comet is quite active," team member Dennis Bodewits of NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center in Maryland said in a statement. "The UVOT data show that Lulin was shedding nearly 800 gallons of water each second" - enough to fill an Olympic-size swimming pool in less than 15 minutes. Farther from the comet, solar ultraviolet radiation also breaks up hydroxyl molecules - into oxygen and hydrogen atoms. "The UV will [teach] us about the composition of the comet," Bodewits told *New Scientist*, adding that such studies are interesting because comets might have brought water to Earth several billion years ago. Glowing wind Studying the comet in X-rays reveals how it interacts with the solar wind, a stream of charged particles from the Sun. That's because positive ions in the solar wind steal electrons from neutral gases, such as hydroxyl, that they hit. Since the stolen electrons are in an excited state, "this makes the solar wind glow when it interacts with a comet", says Bodewits. The observations could lend insight into why Mars has such a thin atmosphere. "The Earth is lucky because we have a magnetic field that protects us from most of the solar wind," he continues. "But Mars, lacking such a shield, might have lost its atmosphere because of the interaction with the solar wind." Jenny Carter of the University of Leicester in the UK, who is leading Swift's studies of the comet, says the team plans to continue its observations. "We are looking forward to future observations of Comet Lulin, when we hope to get better X-ray data to help us determine its makeup," she said. "They will allow us to build up a more complete 3D picture of the comet during its flight through the solar system." 346diggsdigg print send If you would like *to reuse any content* from New Scientist, either in print or online, please *contact the syndication * department first for permission. New Scientist does not own rights to photos, but there are a variety of licensing options available for use of articles and graphics we own the copyright to. Have your say Only subscribers may leave comments on this article. Please log in. email: password: Remember me Only personal subscribers may leave comments on this article Subscribe now to comment. *read all 22 comments * Comments * 1 | 2 | 3 * They Aren't Melting Snowballs Fri Feb 20 19:33:54 GMT 2009 by *Michael S* To quote NASA: "Since the visible images have a higher spatial resolution, we use those images to calculate the extent of ice on Tempel 1's surface. That turns out to be a small fraction of the surface, only 0.5%. " "What is significant is that the extent of this ice on Tempel 1's surface is not sufficient to produce the observed abundance of water and its by-products in the comet's coma. " That is to say, the water comets release in their coma does not come from ice sublimating off the comet. More information on the electrical nature of comets can be found here: (long URL - click here) *reply* *report this comment* They Aren't Melting Snowballs Sat Feb 21 15:46:47 GMT 2009 by *W. M.* I was hoping to see someone posting info on the electric universe. Thanks. *reply* *report this comment* *view thread* They Aren't Melting Snowballs Sun Feb 22 00:45:44 GMT 2009 by *mike* i hate to be to critical on things like this, but i have seen a great deal of emphasis going to electrical nature of things and yet rarely see much evidence. I'm a biologist by trade, but physics is not exempt from critical appraisal based on evidence. I find the emphasis on electrical natures quite reductionist, and claims that weak electrical forces can counter gravity seems quite unfounded and a bit generalistic. However if you have located research papers i would be interested in reading them, i gladly open my own theories and opinions for critcal appraisal. I *reply* *report this comment* *view thread* They Aren't Melting Snowballs Sun Feb 22 14:31:41 GMT 2009 by *IVAN3MAN* Yet another example of quote-mining and quoting out-of-context by "Electric Universe" proponents. The full paragraph and conclusion reads thus: "Given that the spectrometer has a two dimensional detector, it is possible to make a map of Tempel 1 at the wavelength of the ice absorption bands. That map shows that the bright regions in the UV are correlated with dark regions in the near-IR where water ice absorbs light. Since the visible images have a higher spatial resolution, we use those images to calculate the extent of ice on Tempel 1's surface. That turns out to be a small fraction of the surface, only 0.5%. Next, the temperature map is combined with the color map, showing that two of the three regions are colder regions of the nucleus. Stereo images show the largest area of ice to be a depression 80 meters below surrounding areas. Never the less, the temperatures in this region are 285 -295 K, significantly above the ~200K at which ice would sublimate in space at the location of Tempel 1. "What is significant is that the extent of this ice on Tempel 1's surface is not sufficient to produce the observed abundance of water and its by-products in the comet's coma. The team thus concludes that there are sources of water from beneath the comet's surface that supply the cometary coma as well." The full article can be read here: (long URL - click here) Mission results here: http://solarsystem.nasa.gov/deepimpact/results/index.cfm Deep Impact Home Page: http://solarsystem.nasa.gov/deepimpact/index.cfm *reply* *report this comment* They Aren't Melting Snowballs Sun Feb 22 16:37:22 GMT 2009 by *Michael S* Quoting the full paragraph does not change the findings. Observational findings: "ice on Tempel 1s surface is not sufficient to produce the observed abundance of water and its by-products in the comets coma. " Pure speculation on the part of the deep impact team with absolutely no observational data to support it: "The team thus concludes that there are sources of water from beneath the comets surface that supply the cometary coma as well." Dont confuse observational findings with unsupported speculation. The lack of water ice on the nucleus is just one of about 20 things that fly in the face of the dirty snowball model. You can read more about it here: (long URL - click here) *reply* *report this comment* They Aren't Melting Snowballs Sun Feb 22 16:52:59 GMT 2009 by *Michael S* And speaking of selectively quoting, I noticed you left this part of her response out: "Past efforts with the near-IR spectrometer on Deep Space 1 mission flying past comet Borrelly and from the ground of comets far from the sun and not enshrouded with coma, have yielded no evidence of water ice on their surface." *reply* *report this comment* *1 more reply* They Aren't Melting Snowballs Tue Feb 24 00:21:36 GMT 2009 by *IVAN3MAN* RE: "... ice on Tempel 1's surface is not sufficient to produce the observed abundance of water and its by-products in the comet's coma." That does NOT mean that Tempel 1 does not have any ice; there IS plenty of ice visible in Tempel 1's coma. Furthermore, Deep Impact found that there is a good reason that no ice is visible on the surface. Using an infrared camera, Deep Impact mapped the temperature of the visible surface: http://deepimpact.umd.edu/gallery/Temperature_Map.html http://solarsystem.nasa.gov/deepimpact/results/excavating.cfm The temperature was up to 329 Kelvin (56 deg. Celsius) on the sunlit side, and was as cold as 260 Kelvin (-13 deg. Celsius) on the night-time side. So, everywhere that Deep Impact could see, the comet was hotter than the temperature at which ices of water, carbon dioxide, and carbon monoxide would sublimate. In other words, any ice present at Tempel 1's surface would quickly turn into a gas. It's only at some depth BELOW the surface that temperatures stay cold enough all the time that the Sun can't heat the comet enough to evaporate the ice. The main point of the Deep Impact mission was to excavate material from the interior of the comet -- material that could possibly represent pristine components left over from the formation of the solar system. Deep Impact did succeed in making a spectacular impact and throwing material from the surface, as well as some material from the inside: http://deepimpact.umd.edu/gallery/spectrometer2.html http://solarsystem.nasa.gov/deepimpact/results/spectrometer.cfm However, figuring out which material is from the surface, which is from the inside, and what it's all made of is a puzzle that could take years to solve. *reply* *report this comment* *3 more replies* *view thread* Its Wonderfull To Have People Like You Sat Feb 21 00:57:12 GMT 2009 by *Kevin Heitman* thank you for the delitfull info on the comet. have you any info on the comet Nebrue??? is it a mith?? *reply* *report this comment* The Comet Sat Feb 21 08:04:26 GMT 2009 by *paula* is it trust that their will be a comet in 2012 *reply* *report this comment* *read all 22 comments * Comments * 1 | 2 | 3 * All comments should respect the New Scientist House Rules . If you think a particular comment breaks these rules then please use the "Report" link in that comment to report it to us. If you are having a technical problem posting a comment, please contact technical support . print send This image of Comet Lulin, taken on 28 January, merges data from Swift's Ultraviolet/Optical Telescope (blue and green) and X-Ray Telescope (red). The comet's tail extends off to the right, while a cloud of oxygen and hydrogen atoms extends far Sun-ward of the comet. At the time of the observation, the comet was 160 million km from Earth and 185 million km from the Sun (Image: NASA/Swift/U of Leicester/DSS/STScI/ AURUA/Bodewits et al.) This image of Comet Lulin, taken on 28 January, merges data from Swift's Ultraviolet/Optical Telescope (blue and green) and X-Ray Telescope (red). The comet's tail extends off to the right, while a cloud of oxygen and hydrogen atoms extends far Sun-ward of the comet. At the time of the observation, the comet was 160 million km from Earth and 185 million km from the Sun (Image: NASA/Swift/U of Leicester/DSS/STScI/ AURUA/Bodewits et al.) Enlarge image 1 more image ADVERTISEMENT Click Here More Latest news <#> Apollo 13: Houston, we've had a problem 12:00 05 January 2011 Forty years after NASA's ill-fated fifth moon mission, we tune in to the astronauts' conversations thanks to newly released transcripts Solar eclipse to ring in new year 19:00 02 January 2011 The moon will block part of the sun on 4 January in a partial eclipse visible in most of Europe as well as in parts of Asia and Africa Don't send bugs to Mars 10:00 28 December 2010 A plan to send live microbes to the Red Planet's largest moon risks wrecking our search for extraterrestrial life, argues *Barry E. DiGregorio* 2010 review: 10 most popular space stories 12:00 27 December 2010 The most-read space stories of 2010 include mysterious radiation coming from a nearby galaxy and hints of life found on a Saturn moon *see all related stories * More <#> Latest news Jamaican 'ninja bird' used wings as nunchucks 11:31 05 January 2011 A flightless ibis that lived in Jamaica until 10,000 years ago turned its hand bones into miniature baseball bats to defend its territory and probably its young CES: Thought-controlled iPad app gets in your head 00:41 05 January 2011 Startup company InteraXon is set to debut an iPad app that let's you control onscreen events using only your thoughts. Hollywood's 3D hangover 20:45 04 January 2011 Excitement for 3D movies appears to be waning, as films shot in the high-tech format underperformed at the box office this past holiday season. The solar system spins onto the iPad 19:25 04 January 2011 A new app teaches you about the solar system through stunning images, 3D models and reams of encyclopedia-style entries. *see all latest news * Most read Most commented <#> La Niña and monsoonal winds flood northern Australia Weird warriors: The animal world's dirtiest fighters Movie Camera Sozzled superconductors sizzle with speed Booze myths: The truth at the bottom of the bottle Battle looms over US science funding Most read <#> Most commented Booze myths: The truth at the bottom of the bottle Microwave radiation map hints at other universes No black holes found at LHC – yet Climate myths: It's all a conspiracy 'Space elevator' wins $900,000 NASA prize TWITTER New Scientist is on Twitter Get the latest from New Scientist: sign up to our Twitter feed LATEST JOBS There is no better place to be right now than Texas Tech University NIH Postdoctoral Fellow - Baltimore, MD - Government Opportunities at Sandia National Laboratories Scientists Excellent Opportunity for Medical Geneticist Announcement - The Nation’s only ph.d. in Wind Science Academic Surgical Pathologist This week's issue Subscribe Cover of latest issue of New Scientist magazine For exclusive news and expert analysis, subscribe to New Scientist. * Gain full online access * Current issue content * Content of past issues 25 December 2010 ADVERTISEMENT Click Here Click Here Back to top <#hdkey> Login Email Password Remember me Your login is case sensitive * Forgotten your password? * Subscriber? Activate now! * Register now * Subscribe now * Institutional Subscribers * Athens login close * About us * New Scientist * Syndication * Recruitment Advertising * Staff at New Scientist * Advertise * RBI Jobs * User Help * Contact Us * FAQ / Help * Disclaimer * Ts & Cs * Cookies * Privacy Policy * Subscriptions * Subscribe * Renew * Gift subscription * My account * Back issues * Customer Service * Links * Site Map * Browse all articles * Magazine archive * NewScientistJobs * The LastWord * RSS Feeds * Online Store * Android App * Mobile site home * Science Jobs * Biology Jobs * Chemistry Jobs * Clinical Jobs * Sales Jobs * Earth & Environment Jobs * Engineering Jobs * Maths & IT Jobs * Graduate Jobs © Copyright Reed Business Information Ltd. AdTech Ad [close] <#>